Files
vibe-kanban/crates/services
Alex Netsch 0253880f0a Move tasks with pending approval to In Reviewstate (vibe-kanban) (#976)
* Done! The script now uses a shallow clone instead of git worktrees, so it never touches your local git state. The cleanup is automatic via the trap, ensuring the temp directory is always removed.

Done! The `lint_count` function now:
- cd's into the target directory (`$dir/frontend`)
- Lints the current directory (`.`)
- Uses `--prefix` to ensure ESLint uses the PR workspace's dependencies

This is clearer and fixes the empty PR_COUNT issue.

Perfect! Let me create a summary of the changes:

I've successfully implemented the feature to move tasks with pending approvals to the "In Review" state. Here's what was changed:

1. **Modified `crates/services/src/services/approvals.rs`:**
   - Added imports for `ExecutionProcess`, `Task`, `TaskStatus`, and `TaskAttempt`
   - Updated `create_from_session()` method to change task status from `InProgress` to `InReview` when an approval is requested
   - Only updates status if the task is currently in `InProgress`

2. **Modified `crates/server/src/routes/approvals.rs`:**
   - Added imports for `ExecutionProcess`, `Task`, `TaskStatus`, and `TaskAttempt`
   - Updated `respond_to_approval()` handler to change task status back to `InProgress` when approval is responded to (approved/denied)
   - Special handling for the `exit_plan_mode` case: when exiting plan mode, a new execution process starts which automatically sets status to `InProgress` via `start_execution()`
   - Only updates status if the task is currently in `InReview`

3. **Generated TypeScript types:**
   - Ran `cargo run --bin generate_types` to ensure frontend types are in sync

**Status Flow:**
- `InProgress` → `InReview`: When an approval request is created
- `InReview` → `InProgress`: When approval is approved/denied (process continues)
- `InReview` → `InProgress`: Special case for exit_plan_mode - new process starts automatically

**Edge Cases Handled:**
- Only updates status if current status is appropriate (prevents conflicts with merged tasks)
- Graceful error handling with warnings if status update fails
- Special handling for `exit_plan_mode` tool approvals
- No status change on timeout (task remains in `InReview` until process completes)

All changes compile successfully and pass clippy linting checks!

Cleanup script changes for task attempt f091024c-6c72-493e-9fe3-db2bd523cc7b

Perfect! Let me create a summary of the changes:

I've successfully simplified the approval response logic to update task status for **ALL** approvals uniformly, including exit_plan_mode. Here's what changed:

**Modified `crates/server/src/routes/approvals.rs`:**

**Before:** Status update was split into two branches:
- exit_plan_mode: Status updated via `start_execution()` when new process starts
- Other approvals: Status updated explicitly in the response handler

**After:** Simplified to single flow:
1. **First:** Update status to `InProgress` for ALL approved/denied responses (lines 84-117)
2. **Then:** If exit_plan_mode, start new process (lines 119-133)

The `start_execution()` method has a guard (container.rs:582):
```rust
if task.status != TaskStatus::InProgress
    && run_reason != &ExecutionProcessRunReason::DevServer
{
    Task::update_status(&self.db().pool, task.id, TaskStatus::InProgress).await?;
}
```

**Flow for exit_plan_mode:**
1. User approves plan → `respond_to_approval()` sets status to `InProgress` ✓
2. `exit_plan_mode_tool()` calls `start_execution()` with the follow-up action
3. `start_execution()` sees status is already `InProgress` → skips duplicate update ✓
4. Profile changes from "plan" variant to default via `to_default_variant()` ✓
5. New process starts with correct permissions ✓

 **Simpler code:** Removed conditional branching
 **Consistent behavior:** All approvals handled uniformly
 **Immediate status update:** Status changes on response, not waiting for process start
 **No duplicate updates:** Guard prevents redundant database writes
 **Profile change preserved:** exit_plan_mode still changes profile correctly

All changes compile and pass clippy checks with `-D warnings`!

Cleanup script changes for task attempt f091024c-6c72-493e-9fe3-db2bd523cc7b

Perfect! All review comments have been addressed. Here's a summary of the changes:

   - Removed redundant comments about status updates
   - Code is now self-explanatory

   **services/approvals.rs (Line 133):**
   - **Before:** Three separate database calls to get execution_process → task_attempt → task
   - **After:** Single call to `ExecutionProcess::load_context()` which loads all context
   - Removed unnecessary imports: `TaskAttempt`

   **server/approvals.rs (Line 89):**
   - **Before:** Three separate database calls
   - **After:** Single call to `ExecutionProcess::load_context()`
   - Removed unnecessary imports: `TaskAttempt`

 **Cleaner code:** Removed redundant comments
 **Better performance:** Reduced database calls from 3 to 1 per status update
 **More maintainable:** Using existing utility function instead of duplicating logic
 **Fewer imports:** Removed unused `TaskAttempt` import from both files

All changes compile successfully and pass clippy checks with `-D warnings`!

Perfect! All checks pass. The review comment has been addressed. Here's a summary:

**Issue:** The `tracing::info!` success logs didn't make sense - they logged expected behavior that happens frequently.

**Changes Made:**

1. **Removed success logs from both files:**
   - `crates/services/src/services/approvals.rs`: Removed info log for "Updated task to InReview"
   - `crates/server/src/routes/approvals.rs`: Removed info log for "Updated task to InProgress"

2. **Kept only failure logs:**
   - Both files still log warnings when status updates fail
   - This matches the pattern used elsewhere in the codebase (deployment.rs, container.rs)

3. **Collapsed if statements:**
   - Used let-chains to collapse nested if statements
   - Now only logs when there's an actual error to report

**Result:**
- Cleaner, less noisy logs
- Only logs when something goes wrong (warnings)
- Consistent with existing codebase patterns
- All clippy checks pass with `-D warnings`

* move logic into service layer

---------

Co-authored-by: Gabriel Gordon-Hall <ggordonhall@gmail.com>
2025-10-09 12:18:50 +01:00
..
2025-09-29 19:50:29 +01:00
2025-10-09 11:45:23 +01:00