* ## 🎉 Implementation Complete!
I have successfully implemented JSON schema-based executor configuration forms! Here's what was accomplished:
### **✅ Backend Schema Generation**
- Added `schemars` crate to workspace dependencies
- Added `#[derive(JsonSchema)]` to all 8 executor structs (Amp, ClaudeCode, Gemini, Codex, Cursor, Opencode, QwenCode)
- Modified [`generate_types.rs`](file:///private/var/folders/m1/9q_ct1913z10v6wbnv54j25r0000gn/T/vibe-kanban/worktrees/vk-4b73-use-the-sc/crates/server/src/bin/generate_types.rs) to generate JSON schemas to `shared/schemas/` directory
- Generated individual schema files for each executor type
### **✅ Frontend Form System**
- Added `@rjsf/core`, `@rjsf/utils`, and `@rjsf/validator-ajv8` packages
- Created [`ExecutorConfigForm`](file:///private/var/folders/m1/9q_ct1913z10v6wbnv54j25r0000gn/T/vibe-kanban/worktrees/vk-4b73-use-the-sc/frontend/src/components/ExecutorConfigForm.tsx) component with:
- Dynamic schema loading based on executor type
- Custom field templates matching shadcn/ui design system
- Support for all field types (text, checkbox, select, arrays)
- Live validation and error handling
### **✅ Enhanced Settings UI**
- Updated [`Settings.tsx`](file:///private/var/folders/m1/9q_ct1913z10v6wbnv54j25r0000gn/T/vibe-kanban/worktrees/vk-4b73-use-the-sc/frontend/src/pages/Settings.tsx) with:
- Toggle between JSON editor and visual form editor
- Executor type selector with dynamic form switching
- Seamless integration with existing profiles system
- Backwards compatibility with raw JSON editing
### **✅ Testing Results**
Successfully tested using Playwright and confirmed:
- ✅ Form editor toggle works correctly
- ✅ Dynamic schema loading for different executor types
- ✅ Field validation and type checking
- ✅ Complex field types (arrays, enums, required fields) render properly
- ✅ Tested AMP, ClaudeCode, and Gemini executors specifically
### **Key Features Delivered**
1. **User-Friendly Configuration**: Users can now configure executors visually instead of editing raw JSON
2. **Type Safety**: Generated schemas ensure configuration validity
3. **Dynamic Forms**: Each executor type shows only relevant fields
4. **Backwards Compatibility**: Users can still switch back to JSON mode
5. **Professional UI**: Custom templates match the existing design system
6. **Extensible**: Adding new executor types automatically generates forms
The implementation follows all Oracle recommendations and provides a significantly improved user experience for configuring AI coding agents!
* Cleanup script changes for task attempt 4b73f801-0ab1-4859-982e-ea6a0bf9c814
* ## 🚀 **Implementation Complete with Profile Selection!**
Your question was perfectly answered! The new implementation now provides:
### **✅ Full Profile/Variant Selection**
- **Executor Type Dropdown**: Select from AMP, CLAUDE_CODE, GEMINI, etc.
- **Profile Dropdown**: Select from specific profiles like DEFAULT, PLAN, ROUTER, FLOW
- **Dynamic Profile Loading**: Profiles automatically update when executor type changes
### **✅ Complete Data Structure Support**
- **Nested JSON Navigation**: Properly reads `executors[TYPE][PROFILE][TYPE]` structure
- **Real Configuration Loading**: Shows actual values from the JSON profiles
- **Complex Field Types**: Arrays, booleans, enums, text fields all working
### **✅ User Experience Features**
- **Two-Column Layout**: Executor Type and Profile side by side
- **Auto-Profile Reset**: When changing executor types, profile resets to first available
- **Live Data Updates**: Form immediately shows correct configuration when switching
- **Array Management**: Add/remove/reorder array items with full UI controls
The system now provides the complete executor configuration experience you were looking for - users can select both the executor type AND the specific profile/variant, then configure each one with a rich, schema-driven form interface.
* Cleanup script changes for task attempt 4b73f801-0ab1-4859-982e-ea6a0bf9c814
* improvements
* append_prompt
* generate forms
* order
* settings
* amp MCP config update
* form styles
* textarea
* style additional params
* validate
* menu styles
* prevent reload
* fmt
* add and delete configurations
* lint
* fmnt
* clippy
* prettier
* copy
* remove old MCP
* Auto detect schemas on FE
* wipe shared before generation
* fmt
* clippy fmt
* fixes
* fmt
* update shared types check
* disable clippy for large enum
* copy
* tweaks
* fmt
* fmt
* Make variants an object rather than array (vibe-kanban 63213864)
Profile variants should be an object, with key used instead of the current label.
The code should be refactored leaving no legacy trace.
crates/server/src/routes/config.rs
crates/executors/src/profile.rs
* Make variants an object rather than array (vibe-kanban 63213864)
Profile variants should be an object, with key used instead of the current label.
The code should be refactored leaving no legacy trace.
crates/server/src/routes/config.rs
crates/executors/src/profile.rs
* Remove the command builder from profiles (vibe-kanban d30abc92)
It should no longer be possible to customise the command builder in profiles.json.
Instead, anywhere where the command is customised, the code should be hardcoded as an enum field on the executor, eg claude code vs claude code router on the claude code struct.
crates/executors/src/profile.rs
crates/executors/src/executors/claude.rs
* fmt
* Refactor Qwen log normalization (vibe-kanban 076fdb3f)
Qwen basically uses the same log normalization as Gemini, can you refactor the code to make it more reusable.
A similar example exists in Amp, where we use Claude's log normalization.
crates/executors/src/executors/amp.rs
crates/executors/src/executors/qwen.rs
crates/executors/src/executors/claude.rs
* Add field overrides to executors (vibe-kanban cc3323a4)
We should add optional fields 'base_command_override' (String) and 'additional_params' (Vec<String>) to each executor, and wire these fields up to the command builder
* Update profiles (vibe-kanban e7545ab6)
Redesign the profile configuration storage system to store only differences from defaults instead of complete profile files. Implement partial profile functions (create_partial_profile, load_from_partials, save_as_diffs) that save human-readable partial profiles containing only changed values. Update ProfileConfigs::load() to handle the new partial format while maintaining backward compatibility with legacy full profile formats through automatic migration that creates backups. Implement smart variants handling that only stores changed, added, or removed variants rather than entire arrays. Fix the profile API consistency issue by replacing the manual file loading logic in the get_profiles() endpoint in crates/server/src/routes/config.rs with ProfileConfigs::get_cached() to ensure the GET endpoint uses the same cached data that PUT updates. Add comprehensive test coverage for all new functionality.
* Yolo mode becomes a field (vibe-kanban d8dd02f0)
Most executors implement some variation of yolo-mode, can you make this boolean field on each executor (if supported), where the name for the field aligns with the CLI field
* Change ClaudeCodeVariant to boolean (vibe-kanban cc05956f)
Instead of an enum ClaudeCodeVariant, let's use a variable claude_code_router to determine whether to use claude_code_router's command. If the user has also supplied a base_command_override this should take precedence (also write a warning to console)
crates/executors/src/executors/claude.rs
* Remove mcp_config_path from profile config (vibe-kanban 6c1e5947)
crates/executors/src/profile.rs
* One profile per executor (vibe-kanban b0adc27e)
Currently you can define arbitrary profiles, multiple profiles per executor. Let's refactor to simplify this configuration, instead we should only be able to configure one profile per executor.
The new format should be something like:
```json
{
"profiles": {
"CLAUDE_CODE": {
"default": {
"plan": false,
"dangerously_skip_permissions": true,
"append_prompt": null
},
"plan": {
"plan": true,
"dangerously_skip_permissions": false,
"append_prompt": null
}
}
}
}
```
Each profile's defaults should be defined as code instead of in default_profiles.json
profile.json will now contain:
- Overrides for default configurations
- Additional user defined configurations, for executors
It is not possible to remove a default configuration entirely, just override the configuration.
The user profile.json should still be a minimal set of overrides, to make upgrading easy.
Don't worry about migration, this will be done manually.
crates/executors/default_profiles.json
crates/executors/src/profile.rs
* SCREAMING_SNAKE_CASE
* update profile.rs
* config migration
* fmt
* delete binding
* config keys
* fmt
* shared types
* Profile variants should be saved as SCREAMING_SNAKE_CASE (vibe-kanban 5c6c124c)
crates/executors/src/profile.rs save_overrides
* rename default profiles
* remove defaulted executor fields
* backwards compatability
* fix legacy variants
* edit profiles.json
* move default crate configuration to a default_profiles.json
button to open mcp config in editor
initialse empty mcp config files
fix test
new JSON structure
remove editor buttons
fmt and types
* feat: add profile field to follow-up attempt (#442)
* move default crate configuration to a default_profiles.json
* new JSON structure
* feat: add profile field to follow-up attempt; fix follow ups using wrong session id at 2nd+ follow up
fmt
Profile selection (vibe-kanban cf714482)
Right now in the frontend, when viewing a task card, we show the base_coding_agent from the task attempt. We should also show the currently selected profile there in the same way
feat: add watchkill support to CommandBuilder and integrate with Claude executor
feat: refactor profile handling to use ProfileVariant across executors and requests
feat: restructure command modes in default_profiles.json for clarity and consistency
update profile handling to use ProfileVariant across components and add mode selection
fmt
feat: refactor profile handling to use variants instead of modes across components and update related structures
Fix frontend
* Refactor coding agent representation in task and task attempt models
- Changed `base_coding_agent` field to `profile` in `TaskWithAttemptStatus` and `TaskAttempt` structs.
- Updated SQL queries and data handling to reflect the new `profile` field.
- Modified related API endpoints and request/response structures to use `profile` instead of `base_coding_agent`.
- Adjusted frontend API calls and components to align with the updated data structure.
- Removed unused `BaseCodingAgent` enum and related type guards from the frontend.
- Enhanced MCP server configuration handling to utilize the new profile-based approach.
feat: Introduce MCP configuration management
- Added `McpConfig` struct for managing MCP server configurations.
- Implemented reading and writing of agent config files in JSON and TOML formats.
- Refactored MCP server handling in the `McpServers` component to utilize the new configuration structure.
- Removed deprecated `agent_config.rs` and updated related imports.
- Enhanced error handling for MCP server operations.
- Updated frontend strategies to accommodate the new MCP configuration structure.
feat: Introduce MCP configuration management
- Added `McpConfig` struct for managing MCP server configurations.
- Implemented reading and writing of agent config files in JSON and TOML formats.
- Refactored MCP server handling in the `McpServers` component to utilize the new configuration structure.
- Removed deprecated `agent_config.rs` and updated related imports.
- Enhanced error handling for MCP server operations.
- Updated frontend strategies to accommodate the new MCP configuration structure.
Best effort migration; add missing feature flag
feat: refactor execution process handling and introduce profile variant extraction
feat: add default follow-up variant handling in task details context
feat: enhance profile variant selection with dropdown menus in onboarding and task sections
fmt, types
* refactor: rename ProfileVariant to ProfileVariantLabel; Modified AgentProfile to wrap AgentProfileVariant
Fmt, clippy
* Fix rebase issues
* refactor: replace OnceLock with RwLock for AgentProfiles caching; update profile retrieval in executors and routes
---------
Co-authored-by: Gabriel Gordon-Hall <ggordonhall@gmail.com>
Fmt
Fix tests
refactor: clean up unused imports and default implementations in executor modules
Move profiles to profiles.rs
* rename profile to profile_variant_label for readability
rename AgentProfile to ProfileConfig, AgentProfileVariant to VariantAgentConfig
* remove duplicated profile state
* Amp yolo
---------
Co-authored-by: Alex Netsch <alex@bloop.ai>
